What Is Service Charge vs Tip?

A tip is voluntary. The customer decides whether to leave a tip for the employee. A service charge is a set fee the restaurant adds automatically, like an 18% service charge. A service charge is mandatory for customers to pay, so saying no is not an option.

CategoryTipService Charge
Who decidesCustomerBusiness
Who owns itEmployeeBusiness
Optional for customerYesNo
Tax treatmentReported as tip incomeTreated as regular wages when paid out
Counts toward tip creditYesNo
Here's where many people get confused. If a restaurant adds a service charge and gives it to servers, that amount is now calculated as the normal paycheck. It can't be used to cover the tip credit, and it isn't part of a tip pool. Customers often assume a service charge is the tip, so wording on menus and receipts matters. Payroll software helps by keeping the two separate, so each one is taxed and reported the right way.